2001 20 July – John Fosters Resignation Letter


This report resurfaced from amongst the many documents in the joint MRS/MRA archive that was commercially scanned to pdf in 2021. It was then converted to MS Word by David Smith, May 2021.


Mr J Foster
13 Collemore
Sconsor ISLE OF SKYE  IV48 8TD

MRA/fec

20 July 2001

Dear John Many thanks for your article on Ian Clough. I confirm that I will send a copy of otH to Jenny on Publication in September.
I’m sorry that you feel you want to let your membership lapse, especially as you have been a good supporter of OtH with your articles, but even sorrier that you should believe that associate membership was introduced as a device for shoe-horning Tony Jones into the MRA. As a founder member who has been on this committee from Day 1 in 1993, I can tell you categorically that this is not the case. There was no particular individual in mind when the idea was proposed and adopted.
That’s my personal reaction, but this is really the Membership Secretary’s department, and I am passing your letter on to Paul le Bon. In the meantime, thank you for your past contributions.

16th July
Dear Frank,

                     Here is the article on Ian & Jenny to accompany the photographs. I am afraid it will be my last contribution, as I will not renew my membership at the end of this year.
                    You said you would send copies of the journal to Jenny & Robin Kent, & I confirm that her address has not changed, & assume that his is the same.

                    You may remember that at Shap Wells I was critical of the idea of Associate Membership, & especially so when Brian Canfer confirmed my suspicion that it had been initiated primarily to allow Tony Jones into the Association. I was even more concerned because others who were not present would consider that he was being sneaked in, a newsletter beforehand.

                 Over recent years there have been many objectors at the Valley dinner at his continued presence, now that he no longer represents the O.V.M.R.O. Ken McCoy & K.C. Gordon put in a great many years as leader of that team (K.C. still is, & Ken only packed it in when he realised it was 30 yrs. since his first rescue, when at Valley), & no members of the Association know T.J. better than they do. After the vote, Ken summed up the feelings of many; ‘I had hoped we could have maintained at least one Tony free zone.’

                Putting it to the vote of members present at an A.G.M. is apparently democratic, but the great majority would not have known T.J. had they tripped over him. All they had to go on was the nomination of Pete Kirkpatrick, & silencing all opposition was the last straw. That prompted K.C. to say, ‘After that performance I am definitely dropping out.’

               Paddy Millan, Jock Buchanan, & K.C. Gordon have already let their membership lapse, & so too will Ken & I at the end of this year. I will miss On the Hill most, but there are times when principle demands sacrifice.

               I will continue to do what I can for Jenny, she’s such a sweet lass, although she does not always follow my advice.

                                                                         So, ’tis a sad farewell,                                                                                  John Foster







Leave a Reply